Dining

Cape May is known as a "foodies" mecca, with some of the best fine-dining restaurants in the entire state.  But even if you aren't a gourmand, there are plenty of places to indulge your taste buds. Our favorites include Peter Shields Inn and Restaurant, That's Amore, Fins, The Lobster House, Lucky Bones and The Pier House. Look below for these and many other Cape May restaurants. 

Peter Shields Inn and Restaurant

Whether you desire to dine in one of the Inn's 5 inviting dining rooms or overlook the sea on the front porch, the PSI menu and service are sure to delight. Using the finest ingredients their executive chef prepares traditional and contemporary seasonal selection. They also offer a selection of wines from Cape May Winery in addition to being a BYO venue. Reservations are recommended. All major credit cards accepted. Off-street parking.

Website

Lobster House

The largest and most popular restaurant in town, the Lobster House delivers the freshest seafood around at moderate prices. Open daily for lunch and dinner, the restaurant does not take reservations, but you can ask at the front desk about Angel Priority Seating. Can be loud and touristy but the service is fast and efficient. In summer enjoy the outside Raw Deck or enjoy cocktails on the Schooner America. All major credit cards accepted. Off-street parking. 
609-884-8296.  

Website

Lucky Bones Backwater Grille

Located at Schellinger's Landing across from the Lobster House, Lucky Bones is a favorite with visitors and locals alike. The menu offers everything from burgers and brick oven pizza to meat and seafood entrees. $16 daily specials and a $20 wine list makes Lucky Bones perfect for the budget-conscious diner. Moderately priced with a full bar. Off-street parking. 
609-884-2663.

Website

The Blue Pig Tavern 

Located in historic Congress Hall, The Blue Pig Tavern's signature American fare includes everything from burgers and macaroni & cheese to jumbo lump crab cakes and filet mignon. The simple,  nostalgic menu is simple and fresh and uses local seafood and produce in creative, accessible ways. Blue Plate Specials are available daily. Moderately priced. Full bar. 
609-884-8422.

Website

Pier House

Located just around the corner from the Angel in the La Mer Motel, the Pier House offers a wide selection of meat and seafood with a Greek influence. Full bar. Moderately expensive. Open Through Easter Weekend. Look for future construction info when we have it.
609-898-0300

Website

The Ebbitt Room

The Virginia Hotel's acclaimed restaurant is known for its gourmet dining and culinary diversity and offers a comprehensive wine list, fresh seafood and American and international specialties.  All major credit cards. Dress is nice casual and valet parking is available. Reservations are highly recommended. Very expensive. 609-884-5700. Online reservations available.

Website

Mad Batter

For years, the Batter has been a favorite with locals and visitors alike and with good reason. An eclectic menu in a charming and friendly setting make this restaurant a sure thing. Open daily for lunch and dinner. The porch is the place to sit for some of the best people-watching in town. Moderately priced. The Batter now has a liquor license and full bar. Online reservations available.
609-884-5970

Website

Union Park 

The only restaurant in Cape May to receive four stars from the AC Press, Union Park is housed in the Macomber Hotel.  Executive Chef John Schatz has created an outstanding menu featuring the freshest and finest ingredients.  All major credit cards are accepted. Moderately expensive.  Union Park does not have a liquor license but you are welcome to bring your own. On line reservations are available through Open Table.
 609-884-8811.

Website

Washington Inn

Expertly prepared continental-style cuisine, an attentive staff and distinctive setting all combine to make your dining experience a memorable event. The wine cellar contains over 8,000 bottled wines, making their wine list the most extensive in all of South Jersey. Open  for dinner, all major credit cards are accepted, proper dress is required and off-street and valet parking is available. Reservations are definitely required. Moderately expensive. 
609-884-5697. 

Website

That's Amore

This fabulous new Italian restaurant is sure to please, offering a vast menu of authentic meals that would make any Italian grandmother proud. The service is excellent and the spacious restaurant beautifully decorated. There is also a lovely dining room on the second floor that can also be used for special events.

Website

The Black Duck

The atmosphere and food are advertised as "casual, cool", with fresh seafood from local waters, char-grilled steaks and an extensive appetizer selection. Casual dress, all major credit cards, some off-street parking available, along with handicap access. The Black Duck does not have a liquor license, but you are welcome to bring your own wine or beer. Early bird specials from 5:00 - 5:30 at $19.95. 
609-898-0100. 

Website

Merion Inn 

Serving food and spirits since 1855, Watson's Merion Inn is one of the oldest restaurants in town. Fresh seafood and sizzling steaks, along with a full service bar, make The Merion Inn popular with tourists and locals alike. Entertainment by jazz pianist George Mesterhazy nightly from 5:30 pm with a Jazz Trio on Thursdays at 8:30 pm. A real plus is on-site parking. Casual dress, credit cards, reservations. Moderately expensive. 
609-884-8363. 

Website

Gecko's

Specializing in delicious healthy of southwestern and regional cuisine in a relaxed casual atmosphere, indoor air conditioned and outdoor dining available. Geckos  just moved to West Perry St, just before the CVS.  BYOB. Moderately priced. One of our all time favorites.  
609-898-7750.

Website

A Ca Mia

Enjoy fine Northern Italian and contemporary American cuisine in a lovely Euro-style dining room located right on the Washington Street Mall. The menu features fresh local seafood, pasta, steak, poultry, and veal prepared in an innovative manner. The lunch menu has something for everyone -- great sandwiches on house-baked breads, pastas, salads, gourmet pizza and, of course, fresh seafood. Outside patio dining and Early Bird specials are available. BYOB, credit cards, casual dress. Moderately expensive. Parking can be a problem because of its location. 
609-884-6661. 

Website

Oyster Bay

Oyster Bay bills itself as Cape May's only Steak House and features a selection of sizzling steaks, prime rib, charbroiled seafood, whole lobster, crab cakes and surf & turf combos. The big news is Oyster Bay now has a full liquor license and bar. Located just across from the Acme on Lafayette Street, Oyster Bay has off-street parking. Dress is casual and most major credit cards are accepted. Moderately expensive.
 609-884-2111.

Website

Louisa's Cafe 

Hidden away on Jackson Street, just off the mall, this storefront eatery is one of Cape May's best kept secrets. The eclectic Caribbean/Pacific influenced menu changes daily and is written on a chalkboard in the rear of the restaurant. Desserts are home-made. The dining room seats less than two dozen and tables are set very close together, so it's almost impossible not to meet your fellow diners and enjoy some spirited conversation. Reservations are required and only held 5 minutes, so don't be late. Louisa's does not accept credit cards and does not have a liquor license, so bring cash and your own wine or beer. Because of its location parking can be a real problem. Moderately priced. 
609-884-5882.

Website

Aleathea's 

Located in the famous Inn of Cape May, Aleathea's offers porch dining just across from the beach. Enjoy ocean breezes, as you sample their menu that includes everything from homemade Meatloaf to Chilean Sea Bass and Lobster Penne. Off-street and valet parking is available and all major credit cards are accepted. Expensive; dress is nice casual. Aleathea's has a full bar. Reservations.
609-884-5555

Website

Fresco's

Dine by candlelight in a restored 1880 Victorian cottage at what the NY times calls, the best Italian restaurant in Southern New Jersey. "This award-winning restaurant specializes in Northern and Regional Italian cuisine with signature menu items that include Saltimbocco Classico and Osso Buco alla Frescos," raves the NY Times. All major credit cards are accepted and off-street parking is provided nearby. Frescos does not have a liquor license, but you are welcome to bring your own. Dress is casual and the atmosphere is friendly. Reservation are definitely required. Be aware that Frescos does not offer a waiting area and because of their popularity there is sometimes a long wait even with   reservations after 8 pm. Expensive. 
609-884-0366

Website

410 Bank Street

410 Bank offers diners award-winning New Orleans-style French Caribbean cuisine. Fish steaks, seafood, prime steak and veal dishes are grilled over an open fire with 410's famous specialty sauces. Menu items include Chilean Sea Bass Creole, Blackened Prime Rib and Mesquite Grilled Lobster Tail. Dine in either their Tropical Garden or secluded veranda. Reservations are a definite must, BYOB, casual dress and all major credit cards. Nearby off-street parking is also provided. Like its sister restaurant, Frescos, 410 does not offer a waiting area for dinner and later diners may have quite a wait to be seated. Very expensive.
 609-884-2127

Website

Godmothers

Godmother's bills itself as Cape May's Original Italian restaurant and features classic Italian cuisine in a friendly and casual atmosphere. The pasta is homemade and early bird specials are offered nightly. Godmother's accepts all major credit cards and guests are welcome to bring their own beer or wine. On-street parking is available nearby and reservations are accepted. 
609-884-4543

Website

Good Earth Organic Eatery 

Try something truly home grown. Using local organic farmers to get their produce and fruit they are cooking something fresh and natural every day. They are family owned and operated offering a great menu and black board specials daily. This is a Cash Only, BYOB restaurant. Located at 600 Park Blvd with parking on site. Reservations taken at 
609-898-6161.

Website

Island Grill

Casual Cape May dining just off the pedestrian mall. Located on Mansion St. they open for lunch and dinner. Capturing the essence of Cape May and the Atlantic Coastal regions dining experience in a BYOB setting. Enjoy seafood, steak or their daily specials. 
609-884-0200

Website

Sorry we couldn't get to all the restaurants in town, but space prevents us from mentioning some of our other favorites. All menus are available in the parlor and we try to keep them updated. Many restaurants in town are BYOB, all are non-smoking and a few have rather minor dress codes. Anyone at the front desk will be happy to answer your questions, make reservations and give directions. Happy eating!